Right-to-die referendum blocked by Constitutional Court

By MSV On Feb 16, 2022

Italy’s Constitutional Court has turned down a request to hold a national referendum on the right to die after proponents of the move collected over a million signatures in support, Reuters reported.

Italian right-to-die advocates seek to partly abrogate sanctions imposed on those who assist in the suicide of patients who have incurable illnesses or suffer intolerable pain and have already had palliative care.

In a statement, the Constitutional Court said repealing punishments would not safeguard the minimum constitutional standards governing the protection of human life, “particularly for the weak and the vulnerable.”

In 2019, the court partially decriminalized assisted suicide under certain conditions if local health authorities and an ethics board approved, but it also advised that parliament should pass a law regulating the practice.

Marco Cappato, one of the leading advocates of a referendum, said the court’s decision was “a bad news for those who suffer and will have to (face) even longer unbearable suffering against their will.”

Right-to-die proponents last year collected more than twice the 500,000 signatures needed to seek approval of a referendum.

Parliament is debating a law that would allow terminally ill patients to seek assisted suicide through the national health system and protect doctors from any legal suits against them.

“The Constitutional Court’s decision must push parliament to approve the law on assisted suicide,” Enrico Letta, leader of the center-left Democratic Party (PD), wrote on Twitter.

Italian political parties remain deeply split on the issue, with the centre-left generally supporting it and the centre-right opposed. Pope Francis recently condemned assisted suicide as an unacceptable deviation from medical ethics.

A poll by the SWG research group in 2019 showed 92% of Italians who were asked said they were in favour of allowing assisted suicide and euthanasia. Some 45% said they favoured it generally and 47% were in favour in certain situations.